CUSTOMER SERVICE : Subscribe now | How to advertise | Contact us | Mobile edition | RSS feeds

Hawai'i's Newspaper Online      Wednesday, July 23, 2008


  • Search Honolulu Advertiser:

BLOGS
The Daily Dish
Akamai Politics
The Warrior Beat
Volcanic Ash
Family Tree
Prep Talk
The Hot Seat
Go Jimmy Go
'Lost' in Hawai'i
View Tube
Hawaii Hacks
Island Real Estate
Quarterlife Café
Hoops Talk
Capitol Notebook
Scene It
Behind the Headlines
Wassap Wit Dat!
Caucus Night
Raising Islands

ARCHIVE
Today's headlines
Back issues

FEATURED NEWS
Nation/World news
Movie showtimes
Special projects
Obituaries
Columnists
Photo gallery

CUSTOMER SERVICE
Help page
Contact us
Subscriber services
Reader services
Advertising services
About us
Site map
Corrections
Today's front page

RESOURCES
Discussion board
Traffic hotspots
Phone directory
Hawaiian dictionary
E-mail news alerts
RSS news feeds
Wireless news
Newspaper in Education
Blood Bank of Hawaii

spacer spacer
Blogs
spacer

Behind the Headlines
How does The Advertiser decide which stories go on Page One and which go inside? Steven Petranik, 24/7 news editor, discusses that and other newsroom issues. He also invites others at The Advertiser to write about their roles and wants to hear your questions. He has worked at newspapers, news services and a TV network during the past 30 years.
Reach Steve at spetranik@honoluluadvertiser.com.
Posted on: March 5, 2008 at 2:34:30 pm
Why we rarely report suicides

The subject is suicides, but first a personal note: I’ve changed jobs at The Advertiser and added one word to my title that you might not have noticed if I didn’t point it out. That one word, however, has made all the difference in what I do.

I am now 24/7 Local News Editor — local is the new word. I now oversee most of the local news reporters and their stories, both online and in the paper. I help select and shape the local news coverage.

In my old job, I was more involved in national and foreign news, and in turning stories into reader-friendly packages of stories, pictures, headlines and graphics. I was at the end of the newsroom process. Now, I’m at the beginning.

Starting this new job has been overwhelming, hence the lack of blog posts. But it involves me in a new set of interesting issues. I’ll start with suicides.

We generally don’t report on suicides. We consider them a personal family tragedy that is difficult enough for relatives to handle without public scrutiny.

Suicides become news, in our opinion, when they seriously disrupt the lives of others or if the suicide involves a major public figure. Any type of murder-suicide is always covered, but if no one else is killed or injured, we are much less likely to report the story. That is generally the policy at most mainstream media.

A reader called to ask why we didn’t cover an apparent suicide Downtown on Monday where someone fell from an office building. The caller said many people saw the suicide or its aftermath.

We posted a brief item about the incident online under the headline: "Fall investigation closes Merchant Street." The story said a person fell onto the road, but we did not call it a suicide. No other person was hurt by the fall, so we did not to report it further, either online or in the paper. We covered the incident solely because it closed a busy road.

In some cases, the evidence of suicide is inconclusive: Was it an accidental drug overdose or intended? Was the fall accidental or not? Usually the police and medical examiner are reluctant to make such a conclusion quickly if evidence is lacking. Sometimes the medical examiner's verdict will come days after the incident. We weigh each case individually.

There is also the concern that publicity might encourage people contemplating suicide to take their lives in ways that is both dramatic and disruptive. According to the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, there is research that shows that suicide rates rise when there are more news stories about suicide or when a suicide is prominently reported.

Many newspeople would also be able to supply their own anecdotal evidence. For instance, soon after Cyrus Belt was thrown to his death from an H-1 overpass in January, there was at least two incidents where people fell from the same overpass. We reported the resulting traffic disruptions online but did not call them suicides.

Advertiser Editor Mark Platte wrote a column about this subject last year that goes into more detail. Read it here.

I’d be interested in reading your thoughts on our suicide policy.

Comments:

Comment from: Chicken Grease [Visitor]
Steven Petranik, local news editor, all day, all the time
For instance, soon after Cyrus Belt was thrown to his death from an H-1 overpass in January, there was at least two incidents where people fell from the same overpass. We reported the resulting traffic disruptions online but did not call them suicides.


By leaving the information out regarding the suicide in each instance, don't you end up leaving out an essential part of the story? I mean, if for no other good reason, the readers end up asking, "what? They were pushed off? Killed themselfs, what?"

I mean, you journalists have your journalist rules, but, put yourselves in the readers' shoes sometimes.
Permalink 03/06/08 @ 09:52
Comment from: Beara [Visitor]
Good topic, I was wondering about this myself and had a general idea. I agree with your policy, about suicide being painful for the family and being sensitive to that. Thank you for posting this!
Permalink 03/06/08 @ 11:08
Comment from: Jennifer Cole [Visitor]
I see the logic in not wanting to report suicides as a pseudo-preventative measure, however I believe a journalist, as someone who serves the public interest, should exercise some type of compromise here. We need to communicate more about suicide to prevent it. If it's not one thing, a story about someone who committed suicide for example, that drives someone to do the same, it will be something else. Even though I can see the logic in not reporting suicides, I don't believe that people 'waiting in the suicide wings' go scanning through the news every day looking for a way some local person succeeded in taking their own life. If they are, it's a desparate measure, and they've more than likely attempted suicide already.

I do believe, just as details are revealed to the depressed in the reporting of a suicide, it also provides necessary info to those who love them and watch out for them, and reveals to us the warning signs in a relevant and practical way. If I saw someone looking up the office building where someone jumped to their death, I'd do something. Maybe not lecture , but make eye contact, a friendly smile, or maybe a touch on the arm. Sometimes that's all that's needed to pull someone back from the edge.

It's possible that had I not known about the incident, I'd think the person was just wondering if it was going to rain, or maybe looking up at a plane, and I'd just walk by.

It's all very theoretical though. I think that people who blame the media for someone's suicide are negligent in assuming responsibility for others. We are all our brother's(and sister's)keepers.
Permalink 03/06/08 @ 11:20
Comment from: Chicken Grease [Visitor]

I dunno, I don't mean to make trouble, but, I'm still unconvinced as to why the fact that a suicide occurred isn't the Advertiser's responsibility to report it as such.

I mean . . . non-reporting of suicide(s) . . . what'll be on the chopping block for tomorrow?

How 'bout this: news agencies, like The Honolulu Advertiser have no qualms reporting the names of those accused of crimes who might end up judged as innocent following a trial or settlement.

By virtue of how the media (at least in the Advertiser's case)'s thinking of the feelings of those relatives or loved ones of the "suicidor" in not reporting the latter's name or the fact that a suicide occurred, shouldn't the Advertiser [gasp! This is taking long to write] have similar guidelines where the name or details of those merely accused of a crime is allowed the same sensibilities offered by the paper.

Or does "a man was arrested" without saying his name or age affect the bo$t$tom lin$e?

Permalink 03/06/08 @ 14:38
Comment from: franksabunch [Visitor] · http://www.xanga.com/franksabunch
The last thing we need is a teenager seeing suicide as a way to go out in glory for all to see.
Permalink 03/07/08 @ 10:19
Comment from: Kakaako Blogger [Visitor] · http://www.myadvertiser.com/kakaako
I say it's a good call. By reporting it, you might inadvertently encourage some disturbed person to do the same--go out in a "blaze of glory," as they may interpret it. Also, suicide is a deeply personal issue. Yes, individuals and groups are hurt by homicides and accidents, but I think suicide really opens up huge scabs that have been picked on for years, and leaves little room for closure.
Permalink 03/11/08 @ 14:25
Comment from: Ron [Visitor]
The Advertiser has the right policy. For those in distress seeking the last way out, having their presence on earth marked in the paper would definitely be a source of encouragement, making treatment much more difficult.

I recall the incident of a middle aged co-worker over 20 years ago. We were called into a hastily called meeting early one morning and given the difficult news. Most of us didn't know of the person's struggle, and the ones that knew were very bummed. I'm sure people did what they could, but it was not enough. It would have been more traumatic for us if it was in the news, as he was a superb person. Hence we were told first. The end came in a public setting and not reported. I still think of that person from time to time.

Then, there are the circumstances that happen within the home. There are several I know of, and it puts a strain on the families and friends.

The topic of suicides should be covered constructively in a general article, and not covered on a case-by-case basis. The ending is the same and nothing more can be done to ease the circumstances of the past, only the future.
Permalink 03/25/08 @ 03:43

Comments are closed for this post.



FEEDS
RSS 0.92: Posts, Comments | RSS 1.0: Posts, Comments
RSS 2.0: Posts, Comments | Atom: Posts, Comments

spacer
Up Arrow Top

Space
MINI SITE MAP
LOCAL NEWS :
Education | Obituaries | Weather | Traffic hotspots | Military news | Discussion boards | Live chat | Columnists
SPORTS :
Surf report | UH sports | High school sports | Recreation | Sports calendar | On the Air | Golf report | National sports
ISLAND LIFE :
About Men/Women | Taste/Recipes | Faith calendar | Comics | TGIF calendar | Tube Notes | Pet Project
ENTERTAINMENT :
TGIF weekend calendar | 4-week guide | Movie showtimes | Dining | Visitors | National arts & leisure
BUSINESS :
Hawai'i stocks | Hawai'i mutual funds | Hawai'i mortgage rates | Island bank rates | Stock quotes | Moneywire | Coming events | Trade Winds | Local resources
OPINION :
Letters to the Editor | Dick Adair's cartoons | Submit a letter | Submit a commentary
TRAVEL :
Travel almanac | Currency rates | Destinations | Sunday travel ads
HELP PAGE :
Contact us | Back issues | Newspaper subscriptions | How to advertise | Frequently asked questions | About us | Site map | Terms of service | Corrections
CLASSIFIEDS :
Classified ads | Shopping | Coupons | Place an ad
PARTNERS :
Jobs: Careerbuilder.com | Cars: Cars.com | Apartments: Apartments.com
Space
© COPYRIGHT 2006 The Honolulu Advertiser, a division of Gannett Co. Inc.
Use of this site indicates your agreement to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy (updated 6/7/2005)

MySQL error!

Table './blogs/evo_hitlog' is marked as crashed and should be repaired(Errno=145)

Your query:

INSERT INTO evo_hitlog( visitTime, visitURL, hit_ignore, referingURL, baseDomain, 
                                    hit_blog_ID, hit_remote_addr, hit_user_agent ) 
          VALUES( FROM_UNIXTIME(1216876040), '/behindtheheadlines.php/2008/03/05/why_we_rarely_report_suicides', 'invalid',
                  '', '', 40, 
                  '38.103.63.17', 'CCBot/1.0 (+http://www.commoncrawl.org/bot.html)')